Canceling a credit card may intuitively seem like a positive step towards managing finances; however, it's not without potential repercussions to your credit score. Surprising to some, shutting down a credit card account can actually have a short-term negative impact on your credit score rather than improving it. Lenders often rely on your credit history to evaluate your creditworthiness, and when a credit card is canceled, important information that demonstrates your reliability as a borrower vanishes from your report.

Before proceeding with the cancellation of a credit card, it's crucial to weigh the pros and cons on your overall credit health. Your credit limit plays an authoritative role in your purchasing capacity, and eliminating it might cause more harm than any potential benefit. This outcome is particularly apparent when the card in question has a high credit limit or is one of your more seasoned credit lines.

Three primary factors are impacted by the closure of a credit account:

1. Average Age of Accounts: Credit history longevity is something lenders look at to deduce your experience with credit management. Closing one of your older accounts may drag down the average age of credit on your report, potentially nudging your credit score downward.
2. Credit Mix: Diverse types of credit — including credit cards, student loans, mortgages, and car loans — can exhibit your capability to juggle different credit commitments aptly. If you close your sole credit card, you risk reducing the diversity of your credit mix, which can adversely affect your score.
3. Credit Utilization Ratio: This ratio represents the amount of available credit you're using and is calculated by dividing your total credit card balances by your total credit limits. A common guideline is to keep this ratio under 30% to demonstrate responsible credit use. By canceling a card, particularly one with a high limit, you reduce your available credit, which could spike your utilization ratio and diminish your score.

While there are instances where closing a credit card could make sense — such as avoiding high fees or reducing the temptation to overspend — it should be a measured decision. To mitigate any potential negative impacts on your credit score, it is advisable to fully pay off any balances and ensure that all recurring payments are redirected or stopped prior to cancellation. Make the choice to cancel credit accounts with a strategy in mind, considering all variables to make the best decision for your financial health.

Is it Better to Cancel Unused Credit Cards or Keep Them?

Unused credit cards might seem like unnecessary clutter in your financial portfolio, but they play a significant role in your credit score. One of the key factors in determining your credit score is your credit utilization ratio, which is the amount of credit you're using compared to the amount of credit available to you. When you cancel an unused credit card, you reduce the total amount of credit available, potentially increasing your credit utilization ratio.

For example, if you have a total credit limit of $10,000 across all your cards and you're using $2,000, your utilization ratio is 20%. If you cancel a card with a $2,000 limit, your total available credit drops to $8,000, and your utilization ratio jumps to 25%. Higher utilization can negatively impact your credit score. Therefore, keeping unused credit cards open, especially those with no annual fee, is often the better choice for maintaining a healthy credit score.

How Much Will My Credit Score Drop If I Cancel a Card?

The impact of canceling a credit card on your credit score varies depending on several factors, including your overall credit history, the credit limit of the card being canceled, and your current credit utilization ratio. Generally, you might see a small dip in your credit score when you cancel a card, but the extent of the drop can vary.

If the canceled card had a high credit limit and you have significant balances on other cards, the increase in your utilization ratio could cause a noticeable drop in your score. On the other hand, if you have a low balance on other cards and a strong credit history, the impact might be minimal.

ALSO READ: Best Credit Cards For Poor Credit Score in 2024

Does Canceling a Credit Card Hurt Your Credit Score?

Canceling a credit card can hurt your credit score, but the degree of impact depends on your overall financial situation. As mentioned earlier, the reduction in your total available credit can increase your utilization ratio, which is a significant factor in credit scoring models like FICO and VantageScore.

Another factor to consider is the length of your credit history. The age of your accounts plays a role in your credit score. If the card you cancel is one of your oldest accounts, you might see a more substantial impact because it will shorten your average account age. However, closed accounts remain on your credit report for up to 10 years, so the immediate impact might not be as severe.

Do You Get Bad Credit If You Cancel a Credit Card?

Canceling a credit card does not directly result in bad credit, but it can contribute to a lower credit score if it significantly affects your credit utilization ratio and average account age. It's important to remember that credit scores are influenced by a combination of factors, and canceling a single card is unlikely to be the sole reason for bad credit.

If you manage your remaining credit accounts responsibly by keeping your utilization low, making payments on time, and avoiding new debt, the impact of canceling a card can be mitigated. Bad credit typically results from a combination of missed payments, high debt levels, and other negative financial behaviors.

Is It Bad to Close a Credit Card With Zero Balance?

Closing a credit card with a zero balance might seem like a good idea, especially if you want to simplify your finances. However, this action can still affect your credit score. Even though the card has a zero balance, canceling it reduces your total available credit, potentially increasing your utilization ratio.

For instance, if you have three credit cards with a total limit of $15,000 and a zero balance on one card with a $5,000 limit, your utilization ratio benefits from the unused limit. Canceling this card would reduce your available credit to $10,000, potentially increasing your utilization if you carry balances on other cards.

Moreover, if the zero-balance card is one of your oldest accounts, closing it can shorten your credit history, negatively impacting your score. Therefore, it's often advisable to keep zero-balance cards open unless there's a compelling reason to close them, such as high annual fees or risk of fraud.

Is It Not Good to Cancel a Credit Card?

In general, canceling a credit card is not recommended unless necessary. The potential negative effects on your credit score, such as increased utilization ratio and shortened credit history, usually outweigh the benefits. However, there are exceptions where canceling a card might be a reasonable choice.

If a card has high annual fees and you no longer use it, canceling might make sense. Similarly, if you have concerns about identity theft or fraud, closing an unused account can be a protective measure. Before making a decision, consider contacting your card issuer to discuss options like lowering the credit limit or converting to a no-fee card.

How Long Should You Keep a Credit Card Before Canceling?

The length of time you should keep a credit card before canceling it depends on several factors, including your financial goals and credit history. As a rule of thumb, it’s beneficial to keep credit cards open for as long as possible to maintain a longer credit history and higher available credit.

If you decide to cancel a card, consider waiting until it has been open for at least a few years. This helps establish a solid credit history. Additionally, avoid canceling multiple cards in a short period, as this can amplify the negative effects on your credit score.

Is It Bad to Have a Lot of Credit Cards With Zero Balance?

Having multiple credit cards with zero balance is not inherently bad and can actually be beneficial for your credit score. Zero-balance cards contribute to a lower utilization ratio, which positively impacts your credit score. They also increase your total available credit, providing more flexibility in managing your finances.

However, having too many credit cards can pose risks if it leads to overspending or difficulty managing payments. It's important to monitor your accounts regularly and ensure you can handle the responsibility of multiple cards. If you find it challenging to keep track of your credit cards, consider consolidating to fewer accounts while maintaining a low utilization ratio.

How Australian Credit Solutions Can Help You Manage Your Credit Wisely

At Australian Credit Solutions, we understand that navigating the world of credit can be daunting. Whether you’re looking to cancel a credit card or manage your credit more effectively, we are here to help. Our expert team provides personalized advice and comprehensive services to ensure you make informed decisions that positively impact your financial health.

Here’s how we can assist you:

• Credit Score Analysis: We offer detailed credit score analysis to help you understand the factors affecting your score and provide actionable insights to improve it.
• Credit Report Review: Our team will review your credit report for any inaccuracies or potential issues and guide you on how to address them.
• Debt Management Plans: We create customized debt management plans to help you reduce your debt and improve your credit score.
• Financial Education: We provide resources and education to help you understand credit management, utilization ratios, and the impact of cancelling credit cards.
• Credit Card Recommendations: Based on your financial situation, we recommend the best credit card strategies, whether it’s keeping cards open, consolidating, or finding low-fee options.

Encouraging Your Financial Success

We at Australian Credit Solutions are dedicated to empowering you to take control of your financial future. By providing expert advice and personalized solutions, we help you navigate credit management confidently and effectively. Our goal is to ensure that your decisions, like whether to cancel a credit card, lead to a stronger financial standing and a brighter future.

For more information on how we can help you manage your credit, visit our website or contact us today to schedule a consultation. Let us be your partner in achieving financial success.